I am running behind on my reviews for a variety of reasons (including an eye infection) and I want to apologize to the Ruskin Group for this failure.
Blue Kiss by Stephen Fife is not a play with which I was familiar. So I sought to learn as little as possible going 'in' because I prefer zero expectations of any kind. Went in a little nervous because 2026 has so far been an amazing year with every single production so far turning out somewhere between "very good" to "excellent in every way." The pattern had to break sooner or later, right?
This show did not disappoint. Was not the exception. Continued the pattern.
Blue Kiss (the title refers to a nickname for someone--which spoils absolutely nothing) is a "two hander," which means it consists of an entire cast of exactly two actors--in this case Susan Carolina Rodriguez and Todd Casey Morris. Did not recognize either of their names (no surprise in a city this size) but am mightily impressed by their performances. A "two hander" puts the overwhelming weight of a play onto two artists, and neither one gets any real moment to relax. Nobody leaves stage for more than one minute or so, and given this remains life not filmed no camera ever pans way or cuts to the other character. Both are in the room with us, practically every single moment. The challenge--which these two meet with grace and power--is to remain absolutely in the present, in the moment for every single second.
The entire play takes place in an apartment wherein Todd's character gets ready to start tutoring Susan's on her upcoming SAT essays. Clearly there's a lot of tension from the moment the lights rise as the tutor engages in a somewhat fraught conversation the phone. Nothing overt, just a hint of pressure, patience, judgment, and a whole brew of very natural dynamics between individuals. We get a sense of someone complex, with many a hidden issue. When the student arrives, we instantly get more tension as these two very, very different people try to engage with each other from an obvious range of different patterns, values, habits, and (more subtly) pains.
By now of course I figured out what many of the audience no doubt had already--these two have some as-yet-unrevealed connection waiting to pretty much explode.
Director Mike Reilly deserves a lot of credit for keeping this show on course. The explosion happens, not in a single atomic blast but more like a few firecrackers, then a grenade or two, ending up with an intense series of artillery barrages! Kudos to the writer for creating such an intricate emotional mine field here, including the fact both these people react to the world in wildly varying ways. Both are full of wounds, full of scars. Some still open and bleeding, or ready to open again. Neither has anywhere near the right answers, although both believe they do. But their complexity, brought to life by these two performers, makes every shock both startling yet feel absolutely inevitable.
And I felt for them both. So much. Both are right, both are wrong. And after getting to know them as well as I did, my reaction was (among other things) to forgive. Not in some generic sentiment, but reacting to what I now know--which, incidentally, includes hardly a single point of similarity between their issues and soul-scars and my own. It did not matter.
Hopefully, I've conveyed a little of how powerfully the script, direction, and performances moved me.
Blue Kiss plays Fridays and Saturdays at 8pm, Sundays at 2pm until May 17, 2026 at the Ruskin Group Theatre 2800 Airport Ave. Santa Monica, CA 90405.



